 |
|
The problem with reviewing wargames
rules is that you really cannot do them any justice until you have played a few
games using them. That means finding an opponent, and asking them to also check
through the rules. Unfortunately I have found that Napoleonic gamers often are
very conservative in their approach to the period, and tend to stick to one set
of rules, and be very partisan in their defence. Hardly the perfect way of
obtaining an objective opinion.
So it has taken me a few weeks to
prepare the review of these rules, and my apologies for the delay in this case.
The rules themselves are printed in
an A4 format, and consist of 76 pages loose bound in a plastic spine. In
addition pairs of play, order and units sheets are provided which require
copying, or laminating for use in future games. The rules are illustrated
throughout with colour photographs that are used to illustrate tactical
formations as well as providing eye fodder.
These rules are not simple, though
they are fast!
Although the game sequence can be
quickly learned there are a lot of stages, and situations, during which units
are required to undertake various tests. However the tests themselves are based
on simply modified rolls of a die, and are quickly worked through. If required
these tests can be made more complex, by adding in national characteristics, one
of the extensive series of optional rules and army lists included in the publication.
Perhaps the most interesting feature
of these rules is the lack of small arms fire. This is because the author has
adopted the philosophy that morale superiority, effected by class, training and
tactical advantage, is the key factor in resolving combat. As someone with a
Peninsular Allied army I found, and still find, this approach questionable, but
worthy of debate. In practice however the three games that I played did not
reveal any major problems, or hugely questionable results.
The key to this I found was getting
to know the rules. Mike has built into the rules a wide range of factors that can
affect a units performance. As the player becomes more familiar with these the
flavour of the game becomes fuller and more satisfying.
Napoleonic rules abound on the market, but there is certainly room for these. Why not give them a try and broaden your mind! Recommended!
Available only directly from the
author Michael Collins: -
Michael Collins
31 Heal Park Crescent
Fremington
North Devon
EX31 3AP
Price £10 in UK, £12 elsewhere (both inclusive of postage)
